Shell Says Support for Energy Shift Will Wane If Prices Soar
(Bloomberg) -- Support for the energy transition will wane if ordinary citizens aren’t able to keep the lights on, a lawyer for Shell Plc argued as a crucial climate case got underway.
Lawyers for Shell said on the first day of the appeal in The Hague that a 2021 ruling ordering the oil and gas giant to slash its greenhouse gases faster had no legal basis, would be ineffective and counterproductive and could have disastrous consequences for the Netherlands.
“If people can no longer pay for their energy or that energy is no longer reliable when you press the button or want to cook food and turn on the gas stove, the support of people in the country here but also in other countries for the energy transition will be lost,” Daan Lunsingh Scheurleer, Shell’s lawyer, said in court on Tuesday.
Shell argued that when a trio of judges three years ago ruled in favour of NGO Milieudefensie and ordered that the firm must reduce emissions by 45% by 2030, it didn’t fully consider the implications for the energy transition. Shell’s lawyer said the court had failed to also take into account affordability and security of supply.
“Shell’s activities and the fossil products it sells, violates human rights. In particular the right to life,” Roger Cox, Milieudefensie’s lawyer, said in court. “Much depends on this case, both nationally and internationally.”
Shell, Milieudefensie and Milieu en Mens — a separate foundation which was allowed to join the legal proceedings — will present their arguments until Thursday, with the final day of trial on April 12. A verdict will likely come in the second half of the year.
Whoever loses the appeal can take the case to the Dutch Supreme Court.
Shell Starts Appeal of Dutch Court Order for Fast Emissions Cuts
(Updates with Milieudefensie lawyer arguments)
©2024 Bloomberg L.P.
KEEPING THE ENERGY INDUSTRY CONNECTED
Subscribe to our newsletter and get the best of Energy Connects directly to your inbox each week.
By subscribing, you agree to the processing of your personal data by dmg events as described in the Privacy Policy.
More gas & LNG news
![BloomburgMedia_SIZVF3DWLU6800_31-08-2024_16-00-06_638606592000000000.jpg](/media/cq0py2jz/bloomburgmedia_sizvf3dwlu6800_31-08-2024_16-00-06_638606592000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133695936067470000&format=webp)
YPF Eyes Sale of Lithium Unit as Focus Narrows on Shale Ramp-Up
![BloomburgMedia_SJ0BEZDWLU6800_01-09-2024_16-00-07_638607456000000000.jpg](/media/a2qljijm/bloomburgmedia_sj0bezdwlu6800_01-09-2024_16-00-07_638607456000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133696800077270000&format=webp)
Harris Rules Out Fracking Ban, Threading Needle on Oil
![Aerial View Of PLN Indonesia Power's 780 Megawatt (MW) Tambak Lorok Combined Cycle Power Plant Block 3](/media/g3kfzgiq/aerial-view-of-pln-indonesia-power-s-780-megawatt-mw-tambak-lorok-combined-cycle-power-plant-block-3.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133694854472630000&format=webp)
GE Vernova begins commercial operation in PLN Indonesia Power’s H-Class gas power plant
![BloomburgMedia_SIYHXST1UM0W00_29-08-2024_16-00-06_638604864000000000.jpg](/media/ywydklfe/bloomburgmedia_siyhxst1um0w00_29-08-2024_16-00-06_638604864000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133694208070300000&format=webp)
US Pipeline Operator ONEOK Inks Two Deals for $5.9 Billion
![BloomburgMedia_SIXI6VDWRGG000_28-08-2024_16-00-06_638604000000000000.jpg](/media/baqdd0m1/bloomburgmedia_sixi6vdwrgg000_28-08-2024_16-00-06_638604000000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133693344067370000&format=webp)
Ecopetrol Loses Two Board Members on Occidental Oil Deal Fallout
![BloomburgMedia_SIU6ZJT0AFB400_27-08-2024_16-00-06_638603136000000000.jpg](/media/pfcfo5bv/bloomburgmedia_siu6zjt0afb400_27-08-2024_16-00-06_638603136000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133692480068100000&format=webp)
Panama Canal Eases Limits That Caused Global Shipping Bottleneck
![BloomburgMedia_SITMI5DWRGG000_26-08-2024_12-00-07_638602272000000000.jpg](/media/1igbao0z/bloomburgmedia_sitmi5dwrgg000_26-08-2024_12-00-07_638602272000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133691472076500000&format=webp)
US Oil Dominance Hinges on Quiet Corner of New Mexico
![Gjoa](/media/ieajrodo/gjoa.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133096019243200000&format=webp)
OMV announces gas discovery in the Norwegian Sea
![Qatar Kuwait](/media/2wfngjqs/qatar-kuwait.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133691492492830000&format=webp)
QatarEnergy and KPC sign 15-year agreement for LNG supply to Kuwait
![BloomburgMedia_SGE9IKT0G1KW00_25-08-2024_16-00-06_638601408000000000.jpg](/media/1fqbutrt/bloomburgmedia_sge9ikt0g1kw00_25-08-2024_16-00-06_638601408000000000.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=240&height=135&rnd=133690752065770000&format=webp)
Sinopec’s Profit Gains as Upstream Strength Offsets Refining
![Thumbnail (1)](/media/avnnkwbu/thumbnail.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133651637018400000&format=webp)
Why data centres and AI could shake up the global LNG market
![Thumbnail](/media/kfob3oys/thumbnail.png?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133600616585730000&format=webp)
Why energy executives expect the world to hit net zero by 2060
![CSIS Thumbnail](/media/o0acqjyg/csis_thumbnail.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133566075809700000&format=webp)
CSIS: long-term LNG demand to reshape global export capacity growth
![Dr Carole Nakhle Thumbnail](/media/gqrpjths/dr-carole-nakhle_thumbnail.png?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133542056370600000&format=webp)
More women in energy vital to the industry’s success
![Vandana Hari Thumbnail](/media/gz3dyktl/vandana-hari-thumbnail.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133511540022930000&format=webp)
India’s energy sector presents lucrative opportunities for global companies
Partner content
![Dewatermark.Ai 1723035294692](/media/0pujudcn/dewatermark-ai_1723035294692.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133675125990530000&format=webp)
Integrally geared compressors cut the carbon and boost carbon capture
![Navigating the trading seas: exploring the significance of benchmarks-1859882229](/media/qlacaiww/navigating-the-trading-seas-exploring-the-significance-of-benchmarks-1859882229.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133613577584600000&format=webp)
Navigating the trading seas: exploring the significance of benchmarks
![New Lng Ship Web 17829](/media/vjrjyypa/new-lng-ship-web-17829.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133179936218300000&format=webp)
Back to the Future(s): the best commodities benchmarks are still physically settled
![Dr Klaus](/media/4eyh2dr0/dr-klaus.jpg?center=0.3953747239980292,0.50683017007953435&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133517897092430000&format=webp)
Ebara Elliott Energy offers a range of products for a sustainable energy economy
![ESSAR](/media/5uafghtj/essar.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=540&height=300&rnd=133524466961070000&format=webp)